Skip to main content
Annuities

Turning savings into
income that keeps coming

Most retirement planning answers the question of how much you have saved. An annuity answers a different one: how much arrives every month, and for how long. It is a contract with an insurance company, it commits your money for a period, and the trade-offs deserve as much attention as the benefits.

Annuities at a glance

What it is
A contract with an insurance company
What it is for
Income, usually in retirement
Death benefit
Not the point, though some include one
Access to your money
Limited, with charges for early withdrawal
Retirement Income Gap Calculator

What is the monthly shortfall, if any?

Before anyone discusses products, it is worth knowing whether there is a gap at all. Four figures and you will see what arrives each month against what goes out. Everything runs in your browser. Nothing is sent to us and nothing is saved.

Retirement Income Gap Calculator

Four figures, about a minute. No contact information required.

Monthly figures, in today's money

Estimates are fine. This is about the shape of the gap, not the last dollar.

Fill in all four. Expenses above 100, and the rest zero or more.

How It Works

Two phases, and a promise in between

Nearly every annuity works the same way at the highest level. You put money in, it sits for a while, and then it comes back out as income.

The accumulation phase. You fund the contract, either with a lump sum or over time. Depending on the type, the value grows at a fixed rate, at a rate linked to an index, or according to investments you select.

The payout phase. You convert the value into income. This can be for a set number of years or for the rest of your life, and that second option is the one people are usually buying. Payments continue regardless of how long you live, which is a promise no savings account makes.

What you give up. Once the money is committed it is not readily available. Most contracts allow a limited withdrawal each year, and taking more triggers a surrender charge. That restriction is the cost of the promise, and it is the part most worth thinking about before you sign.

Fit

When an annuity earns its restrictions

An annuity can fit when

  • There is a real monthly gap between your guaranteed income and your expenses.
  • Outliving your savings is the risk that actually worries you.
  • You have other money available for emergencies and are not committing everything.
  • You value a predictable monthly figure over the chance of a larger balance.
  • You are close enough to retirement that the income phase is in sight.

An annuity is a poor fit when

  • Your guaranteed income already covers your expenses.
  • You might need the money for something else within the surrender period.
  • It would consume most of your savings, leaving nothing liquid.
  • You have not yet used the tax-advantaged retirement accounts available to you.
  • Leaving the largest possible amount to heirs is your main objective.

A common approach is to cover the gap and no more, leaving the rest of your savings accessible. Annuitizing everything is rarely the right answer.

The Trade-offs

What annuities are bad at

These products carry real costs and real restrictions, and both are sometimes glossed over in the enthusiasm about guaranteed income.

Your money is committed

Surrender periods commonly run several years and sometimes much longer. Taking more than the free withdrawal amount during that window costs you.

Fees can be layered

Administrative charges, investment expenses on variable contracts, and a separate annual cost for each rider. Ask for the total, not the headline.

Inflation erodes a level payment

A fixed monthly amount buys less each year. Inflation protection is available on some contracts and it reduces the starting payment, sometimes considerably.

The guarantee is only as strong as the carrier

Payments depend on the insurance company's ability to pay claims. State guaranty associations provide limited backstops with caps that vary. This is worth understanding before committing a large sum.

Heirs may receive less

A plain lifetime annuity can stop paying when you do. Period-certain and joint options address that, and they reduce the monthly amount.

The contracts are genuinely complicated

Indexed and variable contracts have many moving parts. If you cannot explain how yours credits interest and what it charges, you are not ready to sign it.

Annuities are the one product on this site where the sales pressure tends to be highest and the sums involved largest. Take the contract home. Read it. Nobody reputable will object.

Common Questions

What people ask about annuities

How is this different from just withdrawing from my savings?

Withdrawing from savings keeps your money accessible and leaves whatever remains to your heirs, but the balance can run out, particularly if you live a long time or markets fall early in retirement.

An annuity transfers that risk to the insurance company in exchange for giving up access to the money. Neither is better in the abstract. It depends on whether running out is the risk that actually concerns you.

What happens to the money when I die?

It depends entirely on what you chose. A plain life-only annuity typically stops at your death, which is why it pays the most per month. A period-certain option continues payments to a beneficiary for a set number of years, and a joint option continues for a surviving spouse.

Each of those protections lowers the monthly figure. There is no version that pays the maximum and also guarantees a large amount to heirs.

How are annuities taxed?

Growth inside an annuity is generally tax-deferred until you take money out. How the withdrawals are taxed depends on whether the contract was funded with pre-tax or after-tax money, and withdrawals before age 59 and a half can carry an additional federal tax penalty.

Tax treatment varies with your circumstances and the rules change. This is general information, not tax advice, and a qualified tax professional is the right person to confirm how it applies to you.

Should I put all my savings into one?

Almost certainly not, and anyone suggesting it deserves a hard look. The usual approach is to cover the gap between your guaranteed income and your essential expenses, leaving the rest accessible for emergencies, opportunities and the things you did not plan for.

The calculator above gives you the gap figure. It is a starting point for that conversation rather than an answer to it.

What is suitability, and why does it keep coming up?

Annuity sales are subject to suitability requirements, meaning the recommendation has to be appropriate for your actual financial situation, needs and objectives. Expect detailed questions about your income, assets, liquidity and time horizon.

If those questions are not asked, that is a warning sign rather than convenience. The questions exist to protect you.

Someone suggested replacing my existing annuity. Should I?

Sometimes replacement makes sense, and sometimes it mainly benefits the person proposing it. The questions to settle are what surrender charges you would pay, what guarantees you would give up, and whether a new surrender period starts.

Replacement is a regulated transaction with its own paperwork and disclosures for exactly this reason. Take your time, and get a second opinion from someone not involved in the transaction.

Next Steps

Income is one question, protection is another

Retirement planning and life insurance answer different problems. Most people need both considered, in that order or the reverse depending on where they are.

Protection

Life Insurance Needs Calculator

What would need replacing if your income stopped. A separate question from retirement income.

Legacy

Legacy Planning

If leaving money behind is a priority, that changes which tools make sense.

Already have one?

Policy Review

Existing annuity or life policy read properly, including what replacing it would cost you.

No Pressure, As Promised

Been presented with an annuity contract?

Bring it. We will go through the surrender schedule, the rider costs and the payout options with you, and tell you plainly whether it fits what you are trying to do.

Talk With Nour Have a Question? All Insurance Solutions